The process of articles reviewing

Russian

The process of articles reviewing

The reviewer is appointed by the editor-in-chief or the deputy editor. Both the members of the editorial board and highly qualified scientists and specialists from other organizations and enterprises can be invited for reviewing manuscripts. They have to have profound professional knowledge and experience of work in the specific field of science and be doctors of sciences and professors.

The reviewer evaluates: the relevance of research to the global scientific community, the scientific novelty and practical significance of the work, the type and content of the article, the relevance of the Journal's subject matter, the consistency of presentation, the reliability of research results, the correspondence of the title of the manuscript to its content, the informative nature of the abstract, the quality of illustrative material, analyzes the list of references. Based on the results of the review, the reviewer makes a reasoned conclusion:

recommend the article for publication in the presented form (without comments);

recommend the article for publication in the journal after revision;

the article is NOT recommended for publication (with an indication of the reason).

Reviewers are notified that the manuscripts sent to them are the private property of the authors and relate to information that is not subject to disclosure.

The reviewers are notified about the manuscripts being the authors' private owner rights and not being subject to public disclosure. The reviewers are not allowed to copy the articles for their private needs. Reviewing is performed confidentially. Violation of confidentiality is impossible unless the reviewer declares unreliability or counterfeiting of the article's materials.

The term for the article consideration should not exceed three months from the date of starting the reviewing process.

If there is an indication in the review of an article that it needs to be corrected, then the article is sent to the author for revision.

The review is sent to the author without the signature of the reviewer and indicating his full name, position and place of work.

The Editorial Board sends the authors of the submitted materials copies of the reviews and/ or a a substantiated written refusal.

Original reviews are stored in the editorial office for 5 years.

By submitting an article for publication, the author grants permission for the article to be printed in the Journal, including also permission for the electronic text of the article to be placed on the Internet on the Journal’s official website.

The Editorial Board undertakes to send copies of the reviews to the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation upon receipt of a corresponding request to the Editorial Office of the publication.